Home of the World Famous
Muenster Cheese Curds

S502 County Road D
Cashton, WI 54619
Phone: 608-654-5411
Toll Free: 888-320-9469


***April 1st through September 30th***

Please Take Note: All of the items you see are available in our store for in-person shopping ALL YEAR.
Due to the unreliability of shipping services delivery times we can no longer ship during summer months.
We are sorry for this inconvenience and thank you for your understanding.

Shop Our Products


Home » All Products
 
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Horseradish
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Horseradish
In Stock 0
Horseradish Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 8 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Hot Habanero
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Hot Habanero
In Stock 1
Hot Habanero Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 7 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Jalapeno
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Jalapeno
In Stock 18
Jalapeno Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 8 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Port Wine
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Port Wine
In Stock 54
Port Wine Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 8 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Sharp Cheddar
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Sharp Cheddar
In Stock 117
Sharp Cheddar Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 8 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Spicy Beer
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Spicy Beer
In Stock 8
Spicy Beer Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 7 oz.
Price: $5.95
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Swiss Almond
Pine River Cheese Spreads - Swiss Almond
In Stock 20
Swiss Almond Pine River Cheese Spread made with aged natural cheddar cheese. 7 oz.
Price: $5.95
Scrunch
Scrunch
In Stock 99
1# Package of awesome Scrunch homemade Amish candy. Looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Taste of Wisconsin
Taste of Wisconsin
In Stock 20
1 - 16 oz. Cherry Salsa, 1 - 16 oz. Mango Salsa, 1 lb. Cashew Crunch, 1 lb. Scrunch, 1 - 12 oz. Beef Sausage, 1 - 7 oz. Bacon & Cheddar Snack Stick, 1 - 7 oz. Beef Snack Stick, 1 lb. Baby Swiss and 1 lb. Colby Salami Cheese
Price: $79.95
Toffee
Toffee
In Stock 85
1# Package of awesome Toffee homemade Amish candy. Looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy.
Price: $11.99
Turtles
Turtles
In Stock 32
1# Package of awesome Turtles homemade Amish candy. If you're looking for a gift idea or just truly awesome candy, this is it!.
Price: $11.99
Wisconsin Maple Syrup
Wisconsin Maple Syrup
In Stock 89
Pure Amish Made Wisconsin Maple syrup
Price: $7.95
Wisconsin's Finest
Wisconsin's Finest
In Stock 96
1 lb. each of Baby Swiss and Medium Cheddar Cheese, 1 lb. Cashew Crunch, 1 - 8 oz. Jar Seedless Blackberry Jam, 1 - 16 oz. Mango Salza and 1 - 1/2 Pint Maple Syrup
Price: $49.95
« | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next »

© 2014 - 2025 Old Country Cheese, All rights reserved.

Website Design by SusanSullivanDesign.com